A comparison of antigone and creon in the classic tragedy antigone

Yet Antigone herself does not see the conflict as one between the oikos and the polis so much as one between the man-made laws of the city, and the unwritten, permanent laws of the the gods. Literature which deals with the past therefore has a foot in two worlds. She stands up for her rights, so that she can give a religious burial to Polynices. The play thus presents conflicts of principle and of character, but offers no easy resolutions: Antigone's desire for Polyneices' burial may be vindicated by the course of the narrative, but the gods still allow her to perish. Antigone's fixation on honouring Polyneices leaves little room for the development of any other relationship. The following may be recommended as accessible introductions to the play and the genre: Brown, A. One thing is already clear from what we have seen up to this point, namely that the conflict between Antigone and Creon centres on the question of what the right religious stance regarding the burial of Polynices is. In Greek religion, kings had no power to question the law of the gods, however, that is exactly where Creon was testing the waters. Creon and Antigone as Tragic Heroes in Sophocles' Antigone Essay - Creon and Antigone as Tragic Heroes Creon and Antigone, main characters in the Greek tragedy Antigone by Sophocles share some of the same characteristics that make up a tragic hero, but to varying degrees. First, take into account the timeframe in which Antigone was written That the downfall of his family and his personal suffering come as a direct result of his actions is assumed by all remaining characters at the end of the play. Burial was a vitally important aspect both of family and of civic life. As far as we know Athens monopolized its war dead to a degree unmatched by any other Greek state. Anaximander early 6th century BC saw the universe as composed fundamentally from opposite qualities - such as the hot and the cold, the dry and the wet - that give each other 'justice and reparation' for injustices committed, as a result of which some balance is maintained in the universe. The characters appeal to general principles, which place their specific conflict in a wider cosmic context - it is perhaps this feature which has aroused such philosophical interest in the play - but they are not reducible to those principles alone.

Chronologically, it is the third of the three Theban plays, but was the first to be written. But fatal character flaws destroy the lives of the two heroes.

A comparison of antigone and creon in the classic tragedy antigone

Let us first read the most relevant passages in this regard. Creon accuses Ismene of madness since she wants to share the punishment of his sister cf. Indeed, part of this initial speech was quoted by the fourth-century Athenian orator Demosthenes as a positive, patriotic sentiment, a fact which may suggest that Creon, at least at this point in the play, could be taken to embody civic values.

When questioned by Creon as to why she breaks the law, she asserts,?

Epic poetry was performed every year at the civic festivals, which meant that the heroic age was a shared possession for the vast audience in the Athenian theatre, not just the property of an educated elite. I will bury him; and if I must die, I say that this crime is holy: I shall lie down with him in death? Also, Creon chose his own actions that lead to his downfall and takes no orders from anybody. The remaining views recognise various degrees of legitimacy in both arguments, eventually proving the impossibility of the task in discerning right from wrong in this conflict. Although these two characters are both faced with tragedy, Macbeth is more tragic than Creon because while Creon was able to understand his mistake and correct himself, Macbeth was not given an opportunity to change. They do great deeds and have great power or strength. However, Macbeth is manipulated by his wife, which leads to his downfall. We must feel what this character is feeling throughout the story. Questions and Activities: How would the experiences of ancient Greek theatrical audiences have differed from those of modern ones? Antigone is not about Athens' burial of the war dead. Your time is important. Creon closes his mind even to the wise and aged Teiresias despite being counseled,? Antigone is very proud, liker her father Oedipus, who also happens to be a tragic hero; I guess it runs in the family

Cairns, D. Creon, Antigone, and Oedipus have different personalities and roles, but they also share similarities.

antigone vs creon

This is tragic because Macbeth is never given the chance to repent or realize the extent of the atrocities he committed. For some, secular law and rationality, as expressed by Creon, are right, while Antigone's religious approach is to be rejected as irrational.

It is honourable for me to do this and die. Antigone maintains that the truly divine laws or customs the unwritten and eternal laws or customs 33 are those according to which the dead — especially the dead in the family — must be given funeral rites. Although she presents herself as a weak woman and speaks of all the typical female experiences she will be missing with her untimely death, she functions more like a symbol - some say she is almost genderless.

While Antigone was never in a leadership role all three show acts of pride she has some similarities with Creon and Oedipus in the fight within oneself.

Antigone and creon conflict essay

I am his own and I shall lie with him who is my own, having committed a crime that is holy, for there will be a longer span of time for me to please those below than there will be to please those here; for there I shall lie forever. There are differences and similarities in characters, action, and themes between Antigone and Othello. This reinforces how Macbeth was a loyal citizen and was willing to die for his king, even though there was no close relationship between them. Let us first read the most relevant passages in this regard. They both had a taste of fault but unlike Creon who learned to change himself for the better, Macbeth remains stubborn to his death. Macbeth now believes that he is invincible since he can only die to someone not born of a woman. This includes Greek tragedy. This shows how Creon is vulnerable to disappointments, griefs, and sorrows. Sophocles scholars have interpreted the Antigone as a play about a conflict between the human and the divine, the state and the individual, the public and the private, secular and religious morals, and so on. Any type of essay. Both of them suffer from pride and uncontrolled passion. Antigone, on the other hand, is the maverick who dares to defy Creon, initiating the spiral of events that cause both his downfall and realization of his misdeeds. Antigone maintains that the truly divine laws or customs the unwritten and eternal laws or customs 33 are those according to which the dead — especially the dead in the family — must be given funeral rites. Although she presents herself as a weak woman and speaks of all the typical female experiences she will be missing with her untimely death, she functions more like a symbol - some say she is almost genderless. As Creon says: 'This land - our land - is the ship that preserves us and it is on this ship that we sail straight and as she prospers, so will we.

For others, Antigone's argument is the only one with validity.

Rated 7/10 based on 58 review
Download
Comparing Sophocles' Antigone and Jean Anouilh's Antigone